Apple: The Legacy of Steve Jobs’ ‘Inspirational’ Leadership
Business Management

Apple: The Legacy of Steve Jobs’ ‘Inspirational’ Leadership

This Saturday is two years since the death of Steve Jobs. Yet despite much concern in 2011 for the fortunes of Apple, in 2013 the company has seen sales of the iPhone 5S and 5C actually beat previous launches of new phones. Did Jobs define inspirational leadership and how does this legacy live on?

The day after the 1999 film "Pirates of Silicon Valley" was released, actor Noah Wyle (who played Steve Jobs), was sitting at home in his living room when the phone rang. "Noah?" said the voice at the other end of the line, "Yes," answered Wyle, "This is Steve Jobs."

Wyle told CNN Money that his heart started beating through his shirt. Jobs continued: "I'm just calling to tell you I thought you did a good job. I hated the movie, I hated the script, I think if you had spent a little more time and a little more money and maybe a little more attention to detail, you could have had something there. But you were good." The only response Wyle could think of was: "Thank you, sir."

I wonder if the exchange above epitomises the essence of inspirational leadership. Maybe it explains how Jobs managed to get away with his much publicised offensiveness for all those years? Perhaps these three sentences neatly summarise an approach to management, leadership and business. If Wyle's memory is to be trusted, those roughly 50 words show Jobs is a hyper-critical; they demonstrate that he can easily be harsh… but all this simply intensifies the value of his praise.

The nub is surely this: if Jobs was pleased, you would be desperately happy because he was not indiscriminate; maybe arbitrary, but not indiscriminate. Perhaps the dubious take-away for managers and leaders is that once you've convinced others that you know what you're talking about, you can be as nasty as you like because you've already proved yourself? You don't have to be of course, but you can be, and people will still respect you.

When Robert Sutton was researching his book, The No Asshole Rule: Building a Civilized Workplace and Surviving One That Isn't, he found a troubling volume of Silicon Valley leaders believed that Steve Jobs was living proof that being an asshole boss was fundamental to building a great company. The debate has intensified since Steve Jobs' death and the publication of his biography by Walter Isaacson (in October 2011), which revealed so much more about him.

Jobs may have been unbelievably vile to deal with, but his employees valued his opinion and cared deeply about what he thought. This is critical, because leadership itself can be perceived as a particularly emotion-laden process. In an organisation, the leader's mood has some effect on his/her group. One theory is that leaders transmit their moods to other group members through the mechanism of emotional contagion.

But theory aside, what skills do organisations really need to thrive? In an IDG Connect survey last year we asked which skills professionals thought they were lacking from their environments. The findings, based on a survey of 343 IT decision- makers from Europe showed 23% felt creativity was lacking; whilst 40% felt senior technical skills were missing. This is interesting, though not surprising, as when people are asked what they feel is missing they tend to focus on tangible things like "money" for example, rather than intangible things like "happiness".

The same could be said about qualities like "inspiration", "innovation" and "creativity". It is hard to say exactly what these are and even more difficult to guarantee what they will deliver. The fact is, unless you're in one of those creative ad agencies with funky chairs and exciting slides down to the car park, “floaty” qualities can be impossible to talk about with any real meaning. Would more "creativity" at your workplace make it better? I imagine it is difficult to say until it is there.

So what is inspirational leadership? In a recent article about Richard Branson, Forbes contributor Carmine Gallo jotted down what he felt were the seven secrets. This was the typical marketing-style checklist consisting of: igniting enthusiasm, navigating action, selling the benefit, painting a picture, inviting participation, reinforcing optimism and encouraging potential. And whilst I don't for a minute doubt all this is correct, I do wonder if Steve Jobs' example could provide a more prosaic answer: demonstrate you know your business and make others strive to impress you. The more successfully it is done, the more you inspire (on a sliding scale).

This is far easier said than done of course, and most people simply can't deliver like Jobs could, which might be why inspiring leaders are so few and far between.  Maybe the best thing to do is simply quote Jobs? "Innovation has nothing to do with how many R&D dollars you have. It's not about money. It's about the people you have, how you're led."

This brings us back full circle to the fortunes Apple. At the start of September, our Editorial Director, Martin Veitch, wrote a fantastic opinion piece on the bizarre publicity surrounding the new iPhones. As he put it: “In a market characterised by blink-rate change and the new, new thing, Apple is running out of reasons for people to stay loyal.” Whilst in the next paragraph he concludes: “If you build a better mousetrap the world will beat a path to your door. But if you can’t do that then you’re down to baffling them with BS.”

The truth is, despite sales of the latest iPhones, Apple is slowly being caught up by Android devices and Samsung products (especially) are even beginning to take over on the cool stakes.  Yet surely none of this  has anything to do with leadership? Waning fortunes of companies is inevitable because, like the insane popularity of Sony Walkmans in the 1980s and hegemony of Nokia phones in the 1990s, this type of obsessional product-love is unsustainable.

Jobs’ leadership legacy continues to make waves through the world of business management today. His company is still top of its game, (despite numerous other contenders snapping at its heels). Yet Apple has continued without Jobs… and it seems unlikely, that even his much publicised vision would have been an antidote for the real-life truth that one brand simply can’t stay top forever.

 

By Kathryn Cave, Editor, IDG Connect

PREVIOUS ARTICLE

«Microsoft’s Windows Phone European Successes Offer a Glimmer

NEXT ARTICLE

Follow Up: Should Software Testing be Military? »
Kathryn Cave

Editor at IDG Connect

  • twt
  • twt
  • Mail

Comments

no-images

pivertigo on October 04 2013

He's dead. Get over it. He probably was the right man at the right time. Don't make him a saint.

no-images

TJ on October 04 2013

I read the biography and the one thing I took away from it was that Steve had a unique ability to see products people wanted before they existed - as evidenced by the Mac, the iPod, and the iPad. All other leadership qualities are essential in some shape or form, but having a vision is the difference and what made Apple (with Jobs) the company it was. Since Job's departure, the company hasn't, as stated in your article, done anything new and dynamic. And the field is closing in on them.

no-images

Remon on October 05 2013

To say that Android is catching up with iOS is to entirely miss what is happening. The lead on innovation is firmly in Android's possession. Adding to my concern, the quality of Apple's osx releases has noticeably declined. While it is a stretch to say that Apple has lost it's way, there are some troubling issues that Apple has to deal with before things get out of hand. Apple is clearly suffering from the loss of Steve Jobs.

no-images

Alex on October 05 2013

Well, it will be one more thing... You'll see and will be amazed. STEVE will rule the world

no-images

Mike Kaylor on October 07 2013

I totally disagree that Samsung has caught Apple in the cool dept. Maybe for really old people who need a monster size screen to see text. I'm a high school teacher, and the iPhone still is the cool and most coveted phone. Steve may not be a saint pivertigo, but he was an incredible man and an inspiration to millions. And it wasn't just being the right man at the right time. Steve would have done great things no matter what.

no-images

lrd555 on October 13 2013

I agree with Mike. Very few people want a phone the size of their face. That isn't cool. Besides, Samsung couldn't make a feature phone that worked well. I find it hard to be that their products don't crash on a daily basis. My wife went through 3 Samsung phones before they finally got an iPhone. Try to pry her iPhone out of her hands and see what happens.

no-images

pivertigo on October 04 2013

He's dead. Get over it. He probably was the right man at the right time. Don't make him a saint.

no-images

TJ on October 04 2013

I read the biography and the one thing I took away from it was that Steve had a unique ability to see products people wanted before they existed - as evidenced by the Mac, the iPod, and the iPad. All other leadership qualities are essential in some shape or form, but having a vision is the difference and what made Apple (with Jobs) the company it was. Since Job's departure, the company hasn't, as stated in your article, done anything new and dynamic. And the field is closing in on them.

no-images

Remon on October 05 2013

To say that Android is catching up with iOS is to entirely miss what is happening. The lead on innovation is firmly in Android's possession. Adding to my concern, the quality of Apple's osx releases has noticeably declined. While it is a stretch to say that Apple has lost it's way, there are some troubling issues that Apple has to deal with before things get out of hand. Apple is clearly suffering from the loss of Steve Jobs.

no-images

Alex on October 05 2013

Well, it will be one more thing... You'll see and will be amazed. STEVE will rule the world

no-images

Mike Kaylor on October 07 2013

I totally disagree that Samsung has caught Apple in the cool dept. Maybe for really old people who need a monster size screen to see text. I'm a high school teacher, and the iPhone still is the cool and most coveted phone. Steve may not be a saint pivertigo, but he was an incredible man and an inspiration to millions. And it wasn't just being the right man at the right time. Steve would have done great things no matter what.

no-images

lrd555 on October 13 2013

I agree with Mike. Very few people want a phone the size of their face. That isn't cool. Besides, Samsung couldn't make a feature phone that worked well. I find it hard to be that their products don't crash on a daily basis. My wife went through 3 Samsung phones before they finally got an iPhone. Try to pry her iPhone out of her hands and see what happens.

Add Your Comment

  • captcha

Related reading

IDG Connect

Business Management

The Indian Startup Scene

India is changing rapidly. The population is flooding online and numerous businesses are springing up to service them. Some will succeed and some w

GoToMeeting

Web, Video and Audio Conferencing

Training Your Brain to Thrive from 9 to 5

Here’s a frightening statistic: By age 42, the brain begins to power down.  Science is now showing that unhealthy habits and

no-image

Most Recent Comments

no-image

Resource Center

  • /view_company_report/1541/a10-networks
  • /view_company_report/213/brocade
  • /view_company_report/1487/canon
  • /view_company_report/103/cisco-systems-inc
  • /view_company_report/624/interactive-intelligence
  • /view_company_report/31/ipswitch
  • /view_company_report/1219/jama-software
  • /view_company_report/1592/pivotal
  • /view_company_report/506/qualys
  • /view_company_report/1242/teradata

Poll

Does sealed hardware stifle innovation?