The best smart home products of 2017

It’s been a banner year for the smart home, with new players and new products flooding the market. It’s never been easier or less expensive to convert an ordinary home into a technological wonderland. The biggest developments have come with the widespread adoption of voice control, with Amazon’s Echo family way out in front in terms of new products and third-party support. But the Noon Lighting System, which shipped late in the year, is easily the most exciting smart home product we’ve seen to date.

We reviewed a lot of great products this year—and we encountered a few dogs as well—but this list represents our picks for the best of the best. Products needn’t to have been introduced in 2017 for consideration (though they of course had to be available for purchase), and a handful of contenders didn’t arrive in time for us to consider: The Google Home Max, the Nest Protect, and of course the delayed Apple HomePod. We’ll review those as soon as we can. But for now, these are the best smart home products.

Best DIY smart home system: Samsung SmartThings

Samsung SmartThings Dave Zatz/IDG

Samsung didn’t invent SmartThings, but they were smart enough to snap up the startup in its early days. Since that time, the SmartThings platform has gained broad compatibility and melded with other systems. Samsung built it into a mesh router, the Samsung Connect Home, and into a USB dongle that can be plugged into the Nvidia Shield TV streaming box.

There’s a wide universe of SmartThings components for virtually every aspect of the smart home, and where Samsung doesn’t offer a device, you can be sure that some third-party manufacturer has stepped in to fill the gap.

Runner-up: Abode

abode product family with iphone Abode

Abode focuses a bit more on home security than home automation, with optional services that include professional monitoring. This service can dispatch the police in the event of a break-in. The Abode hub also includes battery backup and a cellular radio that’s activated with the professional monitoring option.

If you are looking for a home automation system, Abode is compatible with a broad array of third-party devices and services, including Nest thermostats and smoke detectors, various ZigBee and Z-Wave smart-home products, IFTTT, and Amazon’s Alexa digital assistant (Google Assistant support is in development).

Best home security camera: Netgear Arlo Pro 2

vmc4030p left1 Netgear

No segment of the smart home market has been busier or more competitive in 2017 than home security cameras, but one product rose above the fray: Netgear’s Arlo Pro 2. This is a high-end camera, and it’s priced accordingly, but it is supremely powerful and can be used indoors or out, operating on AC or battery power—there’s even an optional solar panel that will trickle-charge the battery.

You’ll get 1080p resolution, analytics-driven motion detection, and free cloud storage for up to seven days of video clips for up to five cameras. Netgear also offers strong hooks into other smart home systems, including Samsung SmartThings, Amazon’s Echo smart speakers (you can view a live feed from the camera on the Echo Show and Echo Dot), and IFTTT.

Runner-up: Amazon Cloud Cam

2017 amazon cloud cam withcord 30l fd a mntd v1 Amazon

You don’t need to sign up for Amazon’s in-home delivery service, Amazon Key, to make use of its inexpensive and great home security camera. The Amazon Cloud Cam costs just $120, and its feature set rivals that of much more expensive cameras, including full support for Amazon Echo series of smart speakers.

While you won’t get the flexibility of indoor/outdoor placement or AC/battery power operation, like the Arlo Pro 2, the Cloud Cam does deliver 1080p video resolution, infrared LED night vision, two-way audio, and 24 hours of cloud storage for your recorded video clips.  

Best smart bulb: Philips Hue White and Color Ambiance

philips hue white color ambiance 4 pack starter kit box with product

Philips took an early lead in the smart bulb market and hasn’t looked back. It’s also introduced several smart lighting fixtures and most recently increased the number of bulbs in its starter kits from three to four. While some smart home hubs—including the Amazon Echo Plus—can control Philips bulbs directly, you’ll still need the Hue Bridge to change colors and access their more advanced features.

Philips offers an array of support devices, ranging from motion sensors that can turn the light on as you enter a room to dimmer switches you can mount on a wall. Hue bulbs are also broadly compatible with smart home systems, including Apple’s HomeKit, and you’ll even find third-party apps that add fun features Philips didn’t think of.

Runner-up: LIFX Color 1000

LIFX Color 1000 LIFX

LIFX’s smart bulbs are smaller than they once were, but they’re still bigger and bulkier than Philips Hue bulbs. On the upside, they have integrated Wi-Fi adapters, so they don’t require a bridge to be tied into a smart home system or to be controlled by a smart speaker like the Amazon Echo or Google Home.

As its name indicates, the LIFX Color 1000 is an extremely bright bulb, delivering up to 1,055 lumens. And the LIFX app makes it easy to group bulbs together and to access all their special features. We’d like it even more if it was more price competitive to the Philips Hue color A19 bulbs and available in as many form factors.

Best smart light switch: Noon Lighting System

starter kit on wall Noon Home

What’s better than a smart bulb? A smart switch. After all, the moment you flip the switch controlling a smart bulb to the off position, no voice command, no app, and no smart home system will ever be able to control it. And when it comes to smart switches, nothing we’ve seen has wowed us more than the Noon Light System from Noon Home.

Each Noon Director can control up to 10 Noon Extensions, so that one button press—or better yet, one Alexa voice command—can control all your connected lights at once. Each light can be dimmed independently, or you can group them together to created layered scenes. It’s an expensive system to be sure, but the results will knock your socks off.

Runner-up: Wemo Wi-Fi Smart Dimmer

Wemo Wi-Fi Dimmer Wemo

Looking for a more affordable smart light switch? The Wemo Wi-Fi Smart Dimmer is just the ticket. It can’t create layered lighting designs like the Noon system, nor it can match the elegance of the Noon Director’s OLED touchscreen, but the Wemo app is superb and the dimmer can control any aspect of the light that it controls.

The Wemo Wi-Fi Smart Dimmer does have one feature that the Noon system can’t match: It can also control lamps plugged into Wemo smart plugs. And there’s abundant support for other smart home devices and systems, including Alexa, Google Assistant, Nest devices, and IFTTT. And with an $80 MSRP, it’s considerably less expensive than the Noon Director ($200) and Noon Extension Switches ($100 each).

Best smart lock: Schlage Sense (HomeKit) or Schlage Connect (Z-Wave)

schlage sense Schlage

We didn’t review the Z-Wave-compatible Schlage Connect, but it’s virtually identical to the HomeKit-compatible Schlage Sense that we tested extensively. Which of the two smart locks is right for you depends on which ecosystem you’ve adopted. These are commercial-grade locks that will give you an added sense of security as well as broad support for various smart home systems.

You can unlock either model using a touchscreen keypad or an app on your smartphone. The Sense will also respond to Siri if you’re in Bluetooth range. And if the battery fails or you don’t have your smartphone, you can fall back to the familiar reliability of a physical key.

Runner-up: Kwikset Premis

kwikset premis Kwikset

The Kwikset Premis is a HomeKit compatible deadbolt, so it might not be the right choice if you’re living a smart home controlled by ZigBee or Z-Wave hub. But it’s built almost as sturdily as the Schlage Sense and Schlage Connect, and it retains a key slot in addition to its touchscreen and Bluetooth radio.

The interior half of the Premis doesn’t look quite as industrial as the Sense/Connect, so if you’re concerned about how the lock will look on the inside of the door, you might even find it a better choice than Schlage’s offering—if everyone in the family is on the iPhone train that is.

Continue to page 2 to see the rest of our top picks.

Best retrofit smart lock: August Smart Lock Pro

If you don’t want to replace your existing deadbolt (or you can’t, perhaps because you’re a renter), the August Smart Lock Pro is your best choice. It will look nice on the inside of your door, and won’t impact the key side of the door at all. August bundles its Wi-Fi August Connect Wi-Fi bridge with the lock, which means it can connect to just about any smart home platform—including Apple’s HomeKit—and the lock itself is also equipped with Bluetooth and Z-Wave Plus radios.

Thanks to August’s DoorSense feature, the August Smart Lock Pro can not only inform you as to whether it’s locked or unlocked, it can also tell you if the door it’s installed in is closed or ajar. This retrofit smart lock is expensive, but it’s unrivaled in terms of its feature set.

Runner-up: Kwikset Kevo Convert

kevo convert Kwikset

Kwikset’s retrofit smart lock, the Kevo Convert, isn’t nearly as feature rich as August’s, and it’s Bluetooth only, so it can be tied into a broader smart home system. But it will add intelligence to your otherwise dumb deadbolt, it’s super easy to install, and it’s very inexpensive as smart locks go.

The Kevo Convert is a Bluetooth-only lock, but you can add Wi-Fi connectivity with the purchase of the $100 Kevo Plus wireless bridge. While you’d be getting close to the price of the August Smart Lock Pro at that point, you’d still be saving about $60.

Best smart thermostat: Ecobee4

Ecobee4 Ecobee

No smart home would be complete without a smart thermostat to make it more comfortable to live in. And when you consider that heating and cooling your home accounts for about half of your monthly utility budget, a good one can save you a big chunk of money. The Ecobee4 is our current favorite. This latest iteration carries over the sensors that can monitor temperatures in other rooms of your home, helping to mitigate hot and cold spots, but it also features a built-in Amazon Echo, so you can control HVAC system—and the rest of your smart home system—with voice commands.

Don’t worry, if you’re living in a Google Home home, the Ecobee4 supports that digital assistant, too. In fact, the Ecobee4 also boasts broad compatibility with many other smart home components, including our two favorite smart home hubs—Samsung SmartThings and the Wink Hub 2—as well as Haiku ceiling fans, the Apple HomeKit ecosystem, and IFTTT.

Runner-up: Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd generation)

Nest Learning Thermostat third generation Nest Labs

You’d have to be pretty jaded to not be smitten by the exquisite industrial design of the Nest Learning Thermostat. There’s just no more beautiful thermostat to be had. And Nest Labs is to be commended on the work it’s contributed to the Thread network protocol for the Internet of Things.

But in our book, smart beats beautiful—besides, the Ecobee4 isn’t exactly a homely bit of tech to hang on your wall. And that’s why Nest gets the runner-up spot.

Best smart speaker: Sonos One

sonos one angled Michael Brown / IDG

We picked the Sonos One for this category because it’s smart and it delivers great sound and it’s a member of the most affordable, world-class multi-room speaker system on the market. The Sonos One delivers all the features of Amazon’s Alexa Voice Service, but it sounds vastly superior to anything in Amazon’s Echo line. We would have liked to have compared it to the larger Google Home, but we have yet to receive our review unit.

Whether you already own other Sonos speakers or you decide to put them in other rooms down the road, you can control each or all of them with voice commands given to any Echo device. If you’re just looking for a digital assistant to control you smart home (and smart speakers), save some cash and buy an Echo Dot (2nd generation).

Runner-up—A tie: Amazon Echo Show and Echo Spot

amazon echo show echo spot Amazon

So Amazon pulls off a hat trick plus here. While we weren’t as impressed with the other Echo models it introduced this year, the two new Echo’s with built-in displays knocked our socks off. The larger Echo Show boasts a 7-inch display you can watch movies on, it will display lyrics while streaming music from Amazon’s service (a feature Spotify really needs to adopt), it shows editable versions of your shopping and to-do lists, and a whole lot more.

Both it and the more-affordable Echo Spot can make video calls to other screen-endowed Echo’s or anyone with the Alexa app installed on their smartphone, and you can use them as in-house video intercoms, too.

Best whole-home Wi-Fi system: Netgear Orbi RBK50

Netgear Orbi and satellite Michael Brown

We’ve focused most of our attention on 802.11ac mesh routers and whole-home Wi-Fi systems this year. They’re the best networking solution for most homes, because they eliminate dead spots by blanketing your home with near-uniform connectivity. We’ll add more coverage of the traditional routers that gamers and other enthusiasts might prefer in 2018.

In the meantime, Netgear’s Orbi RBK50 remains our top recommendation for most consumers. If your home has ethernet in its walls, however, we recommend the Linksys Velop for reasons we’ll explain in a moment.

Netgear’s system consists of a tri-band router with a three-port ethernet switch, and one satellite access point. Netgear says this should be sufficient for a typical 2,000-square-foot home. You can add satellites if your home is larger, but we found two to be sufficient for the 2,800-square-foot, single-story, ranch-style house we tested it in.

Best mesh Wi-Fi router for homes with ethernet infrastructure: Linksys Velop

Linksys Velop primary Michael Brown

One of the reasons the Orbi RBK50 is so fast is that it dedicates one of its two 5GHz radios (the third operates on the 2.4GHz band) to data backhaul. The three-station Linksys Velop can do the same thing, but it will automatically switch to even faster wired ethernet for backhaul if that option is available. Netgear has promised to add this capability to the RBK50 almost since it launched, but we’re still waiting.

Note: The discussions of the Netgear Orbi RBK50 and the Linksys Velop were originally published on PCWorld.

IDG Insider


« Native Union Anchor cable review: Lightning cable ideal for your nightstand


Anker PowerLine+ Lightning cable review: Everything you want in a Lightning cable »
IDG News Service

The IDG News Service is the world's leading daily source of global IT news, commentary and editorial resources. The News Service distributes content to IDG's more than 300 IT publications in more than 60 countries.

  • Mail

Recommended for You

Trump hits partial pause on Huawei ban, but 5G concerns persist

Phil Muncaster reports on China and beyond

FinancialForce profits from PSA investment

Martin Veitch's inside track on today’s tech trends

Future-proofing the Middle East

Keri Allan looks at the latest trends and technologies


Do you think your smartphone is making you a workaholic?